Your comments

Thanks Jesse. Oddly enough, I am getting my reset password emails, so I would think that the WP form I am using is the issue... however, when I contacted InMotion support, their representative asked me what my email address was, checked the outgoing email code, and then sent my a copy of the code, saying that it was my email server that had blocked the contact form message.

So I really have not been able to narrow down the problem. The settings for the contact form notifications look ok on my end... it should be going to my email.

I sent an email to Outlook's support team but have not gotten a response yet.